“How Do I Know If This Is Working?”
When a parent asks how to tell if therapy is making a difference, they are not doubting you. They are asking for a framework they do not have yet. Give it to them.
Second in a series on the real conversations Coral Care clinicians have with families.
The session is wrapping up. You are gathering your materials, the kiddo is half-watching from the rug, and the parent leans against the doorframe with a small question that is not really small.
“Can I ask you something? How do I know if this is actually working? I just don’t know what I’m supposed to be looking for.”
This is the question every pediatric clinician should be grateful to hear. It is not skepticism. It is a parent telling you they want to be a better partner in the work and they do not have the framework yet. Your job is to give it to them.
The first answer is: you set the measurement, not them
Most parents are watching for a vague, global sense of “is she catching up.” That measurement is almost guaranteed to feel like it is failing. Catching up is a comparison to a moving target. Other kids keep developing. The gap can stay the same or even widen while real progress is happening underneath.
The reframe is to teach parents what to look for instead. Therapy is working when specific, agreed-upon skills are moving in the right direction at a clinically reasonable pace. Not when the child becomes indistinguishable from a peer. Those are different goals.
Therapy is working when the right things are changing. Not when everything is.
Give them a baseline they can hold in their head
If a parent cannot tell you what their child could do eight weeks ago, they will never be able to tell whether therapy is working. The single most useful thing you can do is give them a baseline in plain language.
This is not the same as your evaluation report. The eval lives in a folder. The baseline lives in their head. It needs to be three or four things they can verify in their own kitchen.
Name three to four observable starting points
“When we started in March, she was using mostly one-word requests. She tolerated five minutes at the table. She got frustrated within two prompts.” Specific. Concrete. Verifiable.
Give them the next-step markers
“Over the next four to six weeks, what we are watching for is more two-word combinations, longer table time, and her tolerating two or three prompts before she taps out.” Now they have something to look for.
Tell them what is NOT a measure of progress
“Her behavior on hard days is not a measure of progress. Her performance with new people is not a measure of progress. What we are watching for is the floor lifting, not the ceiling.”
The four signals that progress is real
When a parent asks how to know if therapy is working, give them a checklist they can actually use. These are the signals worth paying attention to.
Real progress looks like
- The floor is lifting (worst days are less bad)
- New skills showing up in new contexts
- Parent prompts working that did not work before
- Recovery time getting shorter after dysregulation
- Child initiating skills, not just responding
- Generalization without re-teaching
Not actually signals
- Whether she had a good session this week
- Whether she liked the activity
- How she compares to her cousin
- How fast she moves through goals
- Whether milestones happen on the website’s timeline
- Whether she ever has a hard day again
Be honest about timelines
Progress in pediatric therapy is not linear and it is not fast. The honest range for a meaningfully observable change in most skill areas is six to twelve weeks. For some kids, longer. For deeper goals like sensory regulation or pragmatic language, the timeline is measured in months and seasons, not weeks.
Tell parents this directly. The worst version of this conversation is one where the parent has been waiting six weeks for “working” to look like a switch flipping, and you never reset the clock. Set expectations the moment a goal goes on the plan: this is what we are working on, this is the window in which we should see meaningful change, this is what change will look like when it shows up.
Progress is not a moment. It is a slope. A parent who is watching for a moment will conclude that therapy is not working, because moments are rare. A parent who is watching for a slope will see it on most weeks.
Two things that will distort their reading
Even with a good baseline and a clear set of signals, parents will sometimes misread what they are seeing. There are two patterns worth naming explicitly so they can catch them in themselves.
The bad-day rewrite. A hard day at school, a regression around an illness, a meltdown at a birthday party. The parent extrapolates from one bad data point to “none of this is working.” The fix is to remind them, ahead of time, that they will have these moments. Tell them: when you have a bad week, do not change the plan. Change the plan based on the average, not the outlier.
The new-thing eclipse. A new skill emerges, the parent celebrates, and then within a few weeks it stops being the thing they are watching for. Their bar quietly resets. They forget she ever could not do it. The fix is to keep coming back to the original baseline. “Remember when she would not sit for a meal at all? She just sat for the whole thing tonight.”
What to say next time they ask
When a parent asks you how to know if therapy is working, you have a one-minute version of the answer ready. Something like:
“Therapy is working when three specific things change. Here is the baseline from when we started. Here is what we are watching for in the next six weeks. Here is what is not actually a signal, even though it feels like one. I will check in with you on these specifically.”
That gives the parent a job. It gives them something to look for. It moves the relationship from “trust me, it’s working” to “here is how we are both going to know.”
And then you actually come back to it. Every four to six weeks, reset the baseline. Tell them what moved. Tell them what is next. Therapy is working is not a feeling you ask a clinician to confirm. It is a measurement system you build with the family from the first session.
That is what families remember about working with you. Not that you were warm, though you were. Not that the kid liked you, though they did. That you taught them how to see their own child’s progress.
Lindy Myers, M.S., CCC-SLP is the Clinical Lead at Coral Care. She has worked in pediatric speech-language pathology across school, outpatient, and in-home settings, and holds her Certificate of Clinical Competence from ASHA.
Bring this kind of conversation into your practice
Coral Care is a pediatric in-home OT, SLP, and PT network across nine states. We support clinicians in doing the work that actually moves families forward.
Learn about joining Coral Care